The new policy prevents hundreds of scientists working in universities from serving on the agency’s advisory boards, while simultaneously increasing the representation of private companies and industry groups.
Effective immediately, scientists who receive EPA grants can no longer serve on the agency’s three main advisory boards. “Choose this day whom you will serve,” The Hill quotes Pruitt as saying on Tuesday.
— RT America (@RT_America) October 9, 2017
The quote is taken from the Old Testament’s Book of Joshua, in which Joshua led the people of Israel to the promised land but gave them a choice between worshipping God or their ‘false gods.’
“This is sort of like the Joshua principle,” he said. “Either service on the committee to provide counsel to us in an independent fashion or choose the grant. But you can’t do both.”
Perhaps unsurprisingly many scientists slammed the decision.
“This is nothing more than a thinly veiled attempt to try to exclude sound scientific expertise from these advisory committees, and is consistent with efforts to pack these committees with non-science-based interests,” Mark Wiesner, a Duke University civil and environmental engineer who sits on the EPA’s Board of Scientific Counselors, told Chemistry World prior to the announcement.
Rush Holt, CEO of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, said the group “denounces the EPA administrator’s decision to disallow qualified scientific experts from providing evidence-based information as members of its science adviser boards.”
“This EPA decision is motivated by politics, not the desire for quality scientific information,” he added.
American Lung Cancer head: ‘The bill would delay lifesaving protections against ozone pollution,’ https://t.co/vLd7zzTP0a
— RT America (@RT_America) July 19, 2017
Some Democrats were also outraged. “Since he arrived at the agency, Mr. Pruitt has repeatedly worked to silence EPA scientists, deny the facts and discredit science inconvenient to his agenda; now he’s trying to get rid of the scientists altogether,” Senate Environment and Public Works Committee member, Senator Tom Carper said.